Red Dead Redemption 2 is undeniably huge. A map the scale of Red Dead 2’s must hold some secrets, but a lot of people play this game, so surely they can’t stay secret for long, right? Well, turns out they can. After almost a year and two subreddits dedicated to turning over every stone, there are still some mysteries the community can’t solve. Here are 10 of the more popular ones, so you can go out and try to solve them yourself. Happy hunting! 

Spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2 ahead.